I have never been more interested
in musical phrasing than I am now. Perhaps it is
because I have recently been hearing young technically
astounding players with chops up the yin yang and
I am not satisfied. Why? I have been asking myself.
And I think the answer is that, to me, it appears
they are not 'in the music', they are simply showing
off their astounding technique. "Look what
I can do!" in other words. This is not the
way of the peaceful warrior.
I am quite convinced it takes
a good amount of experience to get past the playing.
We HAVE to get past the playing in order to say
anything of real substance. It is not about chops
or those amazing altered lines that we can play
over dominant chords. These are the pursuits of
the music college student. Which by the way, is
perfectly ok and valid. But if one wants to really
make a statement musically, and really say something
of substance, it has to be about the music, not
the musician.
And this does not go for just
guitar players. It goes for all artists with any
instrument, any field for that matter.
If you want to impress another
guitarist who is learning, go ahead, rip through
some changes and show them stuff they can't do.
But if you want to grab the attention of someone
who knows nothing about your instrument, then you
have another challenge on your hands, because someone
who is impartial to your instrument wants to be
moved, not impressed.
Let me put this in no uncertain
terms; we need to intrigue the listener, not impress
them. We are not performing monkeys, we are artists
and until we understand this basic rule, we are
simply not artists.
Now, this may seem tough but I
want to suggest that I am talking on the highest
level here. Everyone needs to go through school,
practice with Jamey Abersold records, play through
changes, get repertoire together. But there comes
a time when we have an audience to play to. And
many musicians simply don't understand why they
do not communicate.
An audience wants to be moved
by the music. They do not need to know what you
went through to get to this place. They simply want
to be moved. And the way you move them is to make
a pure musical statement based on the song you are
playing, not based on your immense vocabulary that
you might have amassed.
And when you come to not only
realize this, but think about these things in a
live playing situation, then you will become a great
artist.
So how do we get there?
There is a great quote from MIles
Davis, who was talking to John Coltrane. Trane asked
Miles Davis's advice on how to end a solo because
Trane was having difficulty finding a place to end.
Miles answered in his raspy whisper, "Take
the horn out your mouth." Space is the place
- Take the horn out your mouth!
And here lies complete genius.
Miles knew, for he thought about this for many years.
Space indeed IS the answer. Phrasing
is the key. I have an assignment for you. Play a
solo over a song you like to play. Play a phrase
to start off your improvisation. Simply play a short
phrase, maybe two or three bars, then end that phrase.
Instead of picking up another phrase immediately
after, I challenge you to wait at least two extra
bars before you play again. This indeed will be
a challenge because leaving that much space would
be akin to us feeling like our audience believes
we have nothing to say. We are used to making ourselves
fill in the spaces because we feel we need to be
saying something. But one thing that is important
to realize, the audience does not hear it this way.
And I challenge you to record
many solos this way. Whilst you are playing, you
may be uncomfortable with this, but when you hear
it back you will hear yourself in an entirely different
way. Don't forget, where there is space in your
solos, there is music, because the band is still
grooving, hopefully making you sound good.
One little drawback with the guitar
is that we don't need to physically breathe. Unlike
a saxophone we can technically play endless phrases
without a breath. The piano is the same. But we
need to breath. Music needs to breathe. When the
music breathes, so can the audience, and when the
audience can breathe, you have them in the palm
of you hand!
Don't be afraid to take the horn
out of your mouth, if it's good enough for Miles,
I believe it is good enough for us.